[Ger-Poland-Volhynia] What a difference a little DNA makes!!!!

Jerry Frank franklyspeaking at shaw.ca
Mon Aug 5 10:25:23 PDT 2013


I am still not convinced about the real value of DNA in genealogical research.  For example, I see nothing of genealogical value in the data you provided at the end of your message.  Can you expand on two things, please.

1.  How has this DNA data either confirmed rumors or dispelled lore?

2.  Of the 900 matches, how many are close enough to establish real relationships?  For example, a third cousin is quite close and here I see real possibilities.  Are you able to verify the relationship by location or records?

Jerry Frank

----- Original Message -----
From: "rhonda simpson" <garynrho at live.ca>
To: ger-poland-volhynia at eclipse.sggee.org
Sent: Monday, August 5, 2013 11:00:15 AM
Subject: [Ger-Poland-Volhynia] What a difference a little DNA makes!!!!

After years of searching for my fathers ancestors in Poland and Volhynia, and finding some things, but not much past my grandparents parents names,  our family had our DNA tested (23andMe).  Dad no longer with us couldn’t contribute, but fortunately my mother was so we were able to separate her contribution to my DNA from Dad’s.

I have to say, my Dad’s Russian/German/Polish ancestry composition was very surprising.  This is just for information for any that may be considering this, this is what I found out.  (plus a bevy of health data which was very informative)

Here’s my paternal ancestry breakdown  1st view is Standard View, 2nd view is Speculative View:  (paternal grandfather born in Lomza, Poland, paternal grandmother born somewhere in Zhitomir and her parents  in Warsaw area).  The following data holds some surprises, confirms some rumours, and dispels some family lore. 

Personally, I am very glad that we had it done.  The other interesting outcome of this is that on their DNA Relatives match, I now have 900+ DNA relatives on my Paternal side that I didn’t know about, ranging from 3rd to Distant cousin.  Boy did my Christmas Card list ever grow, or should I say my Hanukah Card list. 


Standard View
49.8%  European

Northern European

1.5%  French and German
0.8%  Finnish
0.2%  British and Irish
14.8%  Nonspecific Northern European
9.3%  Eastern European
3.4%  Ashkenazi

Southern European

0.1%  Iberian
0.1%   Nonspecific Southern European
19.5%  Nonspecific European
0.2%  Unassigned

Speculative View
50.0%  European

Northern European
8.8%  French and German
4.2%  Scandinavian
1.0%  Finnish
0.7%  British and Irish
12.4%  Nonspecific Northern European
13.1%  Eastern European
4.3%  Ashkenazi

Southern European
0.2%  Iberian
0.2%  Nonspecific Southern European
5.1%  Nonspecific European
Ger-Poland-Volhynia site list
Ger-Poland-Volhynia at sggee.org

More information about the Ger-Poland-Volhynia mailing list